A 4-slice waffle maker is really popular with large families because it can make batch after batch of waffles without malfunctioning. Nearly all of the 4-Slice waffle makers on the market make Belgian waffles because Belgian waffles are a lot more popular than 0.5 inch thick American-style waffles. The best thin square waffle maker is the black and decker 4-slice classic waffle maker and grill/griddle. The Black and Decker Classic Waffle Maker & Indoor Grill/Griddle can open flat to provide you with two cooking surfaces which enables you to make sandwiches, bacon, and hash browns and makes it one of the largest 3 in 1 waffle makers and grills.
Best 4-Slice Waffle Makers Comparison Chart
Features and Specifications | Power Consumption | LCD Screen with Countdown timer | Dimensions (LxWxH) | Weight | Adjustable Temperature Control | Size of Waffles |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
All-Clad Digital Gourmet WD824D51 Waffle Maker Learn More | 1600 watts | Yes | 15.59 x 10.75 x 5.94 inches | 17.41 pounds | Yes (with 6 settings) | 4.5 inch square 1 inch thick |
Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro 4-Square Belgian Waffle Maker Learn More | 1800 watts | Yes | 15.5 x 12.5 x 5.75 inches | 14.5 pounds | Yes (with 12 settings) | 4 inch square 1 inch thick |
Cuisinart WAF-300 4-Square Belgian Waffle And Pancake Maker Learn More | 1200 watts | No | 9.65 x 12.2 x 6.3 inches | 8.23 pounds | Yes (with 6 settings) | 4 inch square 0.75 inch thick |
Krups GQ502D 4-Square Belgian Waffle Maker Learn More | 1200 watts | No | 12.6 x 6.7 x 16.5 inches | 6 pounds | Yes (with 5 settings) | 4 inch square 0.75 inch thick |
Black and Decker G48TD 3-in-1 Classic Waffle Maker & Indoor Grill/Griddle Learn More | 900 watts | No | 14 x 13.1 x 6.2 inches | 8.57 pounds | Yes (with 3 settings) | 4 inch square 0.50 inch thick |
Best 4 Slice Waffle Makers
- All Clad Gourmet Digital 4 Slice Belgian Waffle Maker with Removable Plates
- Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro 4 Slice Waffle Maker
- All Clad 99010GT 4 Slice Belgian Waffle Maker
- Krups GQ502 4 Slice Belgian Waffle Maker
- Cuisinart WAF-300 4-Slice Belgian Waffle and Pancake Maker
- Oster DuraCeramic 4 Slice Waffle Maker
All Clad Gourmet Digital 4-Slice Belgian Waffle Maker with Removable Plates
The All-Clad Gourmet Digital waffle maker with removable plates is the top rated 4-slice Belgian waffle iron with interchangeable plates because it is the only one that has a digital LCD screen, countdown timer, pre-programmed waffle types, an extra browning button, and a reheat button.
The LCD screen will tell you when the waffle maker is finished preheating the cooking plates or cooking your waffles, and it will also display a handy countdown timer and the type of waffle it is cooking for you.
There is a ‘Manual’ version of the All Clad waffle maker with removable plates, which is only the second best All Clad waffle maker because it has none of the digital features of the Digital model including the LCD screen, countdown timer, different pre-programmed waffle types, and reheat and extra cooking time settings. The All Clad Digital Gourmet costs 30% more than the All-Clad Manual Gourmet but it is well worth the extra cost.
The All Clad Gourmet waffle makers have many more features than the Cuisinart WAF-300 and Krups GQ502 but it is only slightly better than the Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro because the Breville does not come with removable plates.
Customer reviews
The All-Clad Digital Gourmet was released in September 2021 and so far it has garnered over 2100 Amazon customer reviews. The All-Clad Digital Gourmet has an average Amazon customer rating of 4.6 out of 5 stars, making it the highest-rated Belgian waffle maker with removable plates. Out of more than 2100 customer reviews, 80% percent of the reviews gave it 5 stars, which comes out to more than 1300 5-star customer reviews. Also 11% percent of the reviews gave it 4 stars and 3% percent of the reviews gave it 3 stars. Only about 7% of the reviews gave it 2 stars or lower.
Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro 4-Slice Belgian Waffle Maker
The Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro was released in October 2013. It is the best 4-Slice Waffle Maker without Removable Plates because it is one of the few waffle makers with an LCD screen, countdown timer, pre-programmed waffle types, reheat button, and extra browning button.
Ever since it was released, it has garnered over 600 Amazon customer reviews. Out of more than 600 total customer reviews, it has received more than 540 5-star reviews, which comes out to about 90% of all customer reviews. Another 4% of the reviews were for 4 stars and 3% were for 3 stars. Only about 3% of the customer reviews were for 2 stars or lower.
• Average Amazon Customer Rating: 4.8 out of 5 stars
• Number of Amazon Customer Reviews: more than 600 reviews
• Number of 5-star Amazon Customer Reviews: more than 540 5-star reviews
• Percentage of Amazon Customer Reviews that were 5 stars: 90%
• Percentage of Amazon Customer Reviews that were 4 stars: 4%
• Percentage of Amazon Customer Reviews that were 3 stars: 3%
• Percentage of Amazon Customer Reviews that were 2 stars: 1%
• Percentage of Amazon Customer Reviews that were 1 star: 2%
All Clad 99010GT 4-Slice Belgian Waffle Maker
The Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro is the best Belgian waffle maker from Breville and it has many features in common with the All Clad 99010GT including a PFOA-free nonstick coating, stainless steel body, and aluminum waffle plates. However, the Breville BWM640XL Smart Waffle Pro is better than the All Clad 99010GT because the Breville Smart Waffle Pro has more temperature and pre-programmed waffle types and only the Breville Smart Waffle Pro has an LCD screen, countdown timer, and overflow channel that surrounds the baking surface for catching overflowing waffle batter and baking it into crispy waffle bites, making cleaning up much easier.
Best Features of the All-Clad 99010GT Belgian Waffle Maker
• Makes 4 square Belgian waffles at one time
• Each Belgian waffle is 4.5 inches wide and 1-inch thick with easy-to-cut sections and extra-deep pockets
• Temperature control dial with 7 adjustable browning settings so your waffle’s as fluffy or crispy as you want it
• Coated with a PFOA-free nonstick material that helps waffles slide right off (coating contains PTFE which is used for Teflon)
• Removable drip tray attached to the back for catching any overflowing waffle batter
• Extra-deep pockets can hold more toppings
• Audio beeping sound alerts you when you can pour in the batter mix, when the device is properly preheated, and when your waffle is done baking
• Steam-release system that prevents condensation or excess moisture from building up allowing your waffles to be crispy on the outside and fluffy on the inside
• Advanced heating technology will evenly brown and bake your waffles so that each bite is the same
• Power indicator light turns red to signal that the machine is functioning properly and preheating
• Ready indicator light turns green to signal that the machine is ready to bake. Then just pour in your batter, close the lid, and turn the knob to the desired temperature setting. After the lid is closed, the green ready indicator light will turn off. The green indicator light will turn back on and you will hear an audible beep to indicate that the waffle iron is done baking.
• Premium, highly polished stainless steel body, and branded die-cast handles riveted to the body
• compact size
• integrated cord storage
• space-saving locking latch and lid allows you to store the appliance vertically
Specifications for the All-Clad 99010GT Belgian Waffle Maker
• Housing Material – Stainless Steel
• Coating on Waffle Plates – PFOA-Free nonstick coating
• 7 temperature settings
• Dimensions (LxWxH) – 16.9 x 13 x 7.4 inches
• Weight – 14.25 pounds
• Country of Origin – China
• Release Date – March 2015
Krups GQ502 4-Slice Belgian Waffle Maker
KRUPS is a great brand that is very well known for its quality and innovative designs. Krups has been a leader in the kitchen appliance industry, including coffee and waffle makers, for over 160 years.
The Krups GQ502 4-Slice Belgian waffle maker is the only waffle maker that they sell. It is stylish, well-built, and will bake batch after batch of waffles for many years to come.
Best Features of the Krups GQ502
• Bakes 4 square-shaped Belgian waffles at the same time (each waffle is 4.5-inches wide and 0.75-inches thick)
• Steam release openings – There are openings in the back and top of the appliance that allows the steam generated from the cooking process to escape through ensuring your waffles are crispy instead of too soggy. The steam results from the evaporation of the water in the cold batter while it is heating up on the cooking plates. You should expect the water to turn into steam at the boiling point of water, which is 100 degrees Celsius. Right before the steam stops coming out of the device, you will hear a beeping noise and the ready indicator light will turn on to signify that your waffles are done baking.
• 0.75-inch deep pockets that can hold berries and maple syrup
• 5-setting browning control knob – You can choose from 5 different browning levels that can create different-colored waffles ranging from light to dark.
• Cleanup will be easy: Removable, dishwasher safe die-cast cooking plates with a nonstick coating ensures your waffles don’t fall apart when you take them off of the plates.
• Thick aluminum cooking plates will give you even cooking: Aluminum is a great heat conductor so it will distribute freely and evenly across the cooking surface. A thicker cooking plate will mean that it retains heat a lot better which means the waffles will be cooked more thoroughly and evenly.
• Red indicator light tells you when the device begins preheating the cooking plates
• Green indicator light tells you two things: (1) when the cooking plates have reached the selected temperature and are ready to begin cooking the batter and (2) when your waffles are done.
• Audible beep indicates when it is ready for batter or when the waffles are finished baking
• Durable Stainless steel housing with a sleek, modern look
• Cord wrap compartment located underneath the device
• handle locking latch that securely shuts the lid
• Space-saving Upright storage
Specifications
• Material – Stainless Steel
• Dimensions – 16.5(Length) x 12.6(Width) x 6.7(Height) inches
• Weight – 9.1 Pounds
• Country of Origin – China
• Release Date – September 2016
Final Verdict for the Krups GQ502
The Cuisinart WAF-300 can do a little bit more than the Krups GQ502 but it costs about 33% more. If you are on a budget and just want a reliable waffle maker, then you should definitely purchase the Krups GQ502 waffle maker instead.